Spoilers

“Witness the Prosecution”

Season four of Picket Fences has been a disappointment so far, but this episode, although it truly stretches the level of believability, is a much better one. It does harken back to an earlier season where shocking things would happen in a courtroom in Rome, Wisconsin.

Say, for example, the Pope would testify in a murder case.

This was definitely a wild episode with some solid work going on, There are plenty of problems with it though. The whole set up for the last minute visit of Pope John Paul II to Rome to visit small town America did not feel accurate. I can’t believe the Pope would do something this spontaneous. 

Secondly, the whole Maxine lusting after the Pope because he was ‘unattainable’ was repulsive and the character did not deserve such a character trait. Maxine has not been treated very fairly in this season of shows.

Another character that has been terribly inconsistent is Douglas Wambaugh. It is as if the writers write him depending on the episode. Some weeks he is a good man with a heart of gold and other weeks he is a slimy lawyer who will do whatever is good for his case. Wambaugh has not been written well during season four either.

I did like the idea that the only witness to a murder was the Pope and that they needed his testimony for a conviction. Admittedly, I do not think that the Pope would ever be in a courtroom testifying, but I do like the premise. And if anyone could get him in the witness stand, it would be Judge Bone.

It was used to put forth the thoughts of the Catholic Church toward homosexuality. That was the topic of the week.

Overall, I liked this episode, but in reflection, it had its share of flaws that a better written episode from season 2 or 3 would not have.