S4 E21-24, S5 E1-2

SPOILERS

“Elegy”

“Demons”

“Gethsemane”

“Redux Part I & II”

With a lazy Sunday on record, I decided that I wanted to go ahead and finish the X-Files season four, knowing that there were three episodes remaining.

However, when I arrived at the season four finale I discovered that it was going to be a three part arc and it was Redux, which I remembered when it first aired as a very key episode. So with nothing else planned, I decided to go ahead and watch the five episode stretch for the day.

The first two episodes of the day, “Elegy” and “Demons,” were both solid episodes. “Demons” especially was a favorite episode as the inner mind of Mulder was explored and the memories of the incident with his sister was examined with a cool new twist.

Of course, the whole Samantha situation is redefined again during the Redux episodes as the Cigarette Smoking Man, in an attempt to tempt Mulder to the dark side, brought Mulder’s sister (or what he claimed was Samantha) to meet her brother. There have been several answers to what had happened to Mulder’s sister, so I remember not believing that this was her when I first saw the episode.

The reshaping of the concept of the series, with Mulder convinced that the government had been orchestrating a hoax with UFOs the whole time and had played Mulder and Scully for fools taking center stage.

Of course, it also saw the end of the Scully cancer storyline. The script does a fine job of keeping the reason Scully’s cancer went into remission debatable. There is the microchip that they reinserted in her neck, her faith returning, as well as the doctor trying to get her body to fight against the disease.

The whole Scully cancer arc was up and down. There were a bunch of episodes that basically ignored the fact, but the resolution of it was well done. The tension with Scully’s brother added some real anxiety to the scenes, especially those with him and Mulder.

CSM was shot and killed at the end of the episode, but it was not a satisfying moment for a couple of reasons. One, because it was not Mulder doing it. It was from a hitman. And two, because there was no body and he was clearly not dead. No body, no death.

Mulder calling out Blevins as the mole inside the FBI was a truly dramatic scene. David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson both had some great scenes in these episodes, in particularly in “Demons” and in “Redux Part II”.