There has been a lot of hatred leveled at this film, and I am not certain the reasoning behind it. Claims of “fat-shaming” seem to fall short if you, you know, actually watch the movie. Now, if they claimed that the movie wasn’t as funny as it could have or should have been, perhaps I would agree.
Amy Schumer plays Renee Bennett, a woman who has a low level job that is matched by her low level confidence. She sees how the world treats the beautiful people and she desires to have a part of that. So when she has an accident during exercising and hits here head, she suddenly awakes seeing herself in a different view. She actually sees herself the way she always wanted to be seen.
We, as the audience, only ever see Amy Schumer as she is, but the perception of herself as a beautiful woman changes the confidence of Renee so that she can get the job of her dreams, hook up with a sweet and kind man (Rory Scovel) she meets at the dry cleaners and become remarkably successful.
While there are plenty of plus sized jokes to be had here, I do not think the main message is fat-shaming. I believe the message is clearly self-confidence leads to happiness and success. If you believe in yourself, you can accomplish anything you want. It does not matter what the world sees you as, but what maters is how you see yourself.
All of these fit together in a solid message that I think is worth hearing.
Now, the film itself is okay, but nothing really jumps out as great. Amy Schumer is very good in the lead role. She is warm and charismatic and delivers a strong performance. Michelle Williams, who plays Renee’s boss, is really good as Avery, a rich, spoiled, yet deeply self-doubting woman (whose voice is like a baby doll). The connection between Renee and Avery is a positive in the film. I also enjoyed the natural feeling relationship that developed between Renee and Ethan, the man she meets in the dry cleaners.
Many of these side characters play against type. You would expect them to respond in certain ways to Renee, but then they stop and do something different. It had a feel of realness about it, despite the silly concept going on with them.
One problem is that the film, which is meant to be a comedy, does not have a ton of laughs in it. It has a few that are nice chuckles, but nothing that really makes you laugh out loud. It is more like an uplifting, crowd pleaser of a film than a comedy. That is not necessarily bad, but fans of Schumer’s may be expecting something else.
The film does also feel fairly predictable. You kind of know how this movie is going to go, and, in the end, that is really how it turns out.
Still, despite it not being a great film, I enjoyed watching it. It may have felt overlong, but the message is an important one for people to hear and Amy Schumer does a solid job delivering it with some entertainment.