2025 Year in Review: Documentaries

It’s been a good year for documentaries, but there has not been one that really jumped out as the best of the year. In past years, there have been some apparent choices.

Best Documentary

Previous Winners:  Won’t You Be My Neighbor?, My Scientology Movie, Tickled, Finding Neverland, Tiger King, The Beatles: Get Back, Lights & Magic, Still: A Michael J. Fox Movie, Super/Man: The Christopher Reeve Story

Many of these were so obvious that you could just pencil it in and plan the rest. Won’t You Be My Neighbor? was as good as it got. The Michael J. Fox and Christopher Reeve movies brought so many feels to my tum-tum that they were clear choices.

This year, I have a bunch of good ones, but none that really demands to be the winner.

Runners-Up: I have not seen the John Candy doc, which I think will be pushed to the June Swoon at this point. I watched the Wick is Pain doc this year prior to Ballerina, and it was an enjoyable time. Being Eddie was funny, but not incredibly deep. Unknown Number: The High School Catfish was an improbable story, and those always make an enjoyable doc. Peacock had the Wrestlemania IX: Becoming a Spectacle, which had a lot of background info on one of the worst Wrestlemanias of all time. A doc on the artist behind Maus, Art Spiegelman, was a nice doc. Art Spiegelman: Disaster is My Muse goes into detail of the iconic cartoonist. My most recent doc was The Secrets We Bury on HBO Max, about a man who found his father’s bones buried beneath his house. I just finished Billy Joel: And So It Goes as part of the Sunday Morning Sidewalk. Becoming Led Zeppelin was a rocking good time. The Perfect Neighbor was another story of a Karen-gone-wrong and almost got this win. The actual second place doc this year went to Titan: The Oceangate Disaster.

Documentary of the Year

WWE Unreal

I know there were a lot of people trashing this as being set up, that the backstage stuff was scripted more than it professed. I don’t care. I found this to be utterly fascinating and engaging. When the agent Chris Park was upset because the Punk-Rollins match was going too long and he kept apologizing to Bruce Pritchard, who sure seemed to be one big jerk about it. Park was consoled by William Regal. That scene was absolutely not scripted and it showed the amount of pressure the backstage agents can feel.

This was four episodes on Netflix and is leading to a second season in January.

Bates Motel S1 E2

Spoilers

“Nice Town You Picked, Norma”

Man, Freddie Highmore can give some death stares unlike anyone else. His eyes are amazingly creepy and, at times, simply frightening. You can see the insanity inside them, making him a great Norman Bates.

Norma’s first son and Norman’s half-brother Dylan arrived at the beginning of episode, creating tension within the Bates family. He had so much anger directed toward Norma, who he did not call Mom, but by her actual name, and the tension between him and Norman was obvious. Dylan’s anger toward Norma boiled over as Norman tried to defend his mother’s honor.

Vera Farmiga played Norma with such a depth that elevated this character into one of the most compelling character on the show. She is so mysterious and enigmatic. You are never quite sure what she is thinking behind each stare. When she was questioning Emma about her disease, I could not tell if she was interested because she was being empathic or if she was saying it to let Norman hear about the things about her cystic fibrosis because she was jealous of any other girl who might have a connection to Norman.

Romero continued to be suspicious of Norma after they found the truck of Keith Summers and a witness had said that Keith was seen arguing with Norma and Norman at the Hotel. Norma is cool as can be during the interactions, hiding the real anxiety beneath the surface. Keith was the man who raped Norma and whom she killed and dumped in the lake. Some of the word play between Norma and Romero was well written and jumped off the screen.

The town that they have moved to is shown to be a darker place than Norma had expected, with a deep criminal underground involved.

After episode number two, the storytelling is excellent. They bring up storylines that continue to service these characters while focusing on the unhealthy relationship between mother and son. A relationship that we know will end up in tragedy.