If you don’t have great villains, your heroes suffer. Every year we look at the best of the antagonists from the year past.
SPOILERS TOO BY THE WAY
BEST of 2016
#10. The Evil Queen and Mr. Gold (Once Upon a Time). These two together have created quite the stir in Storybrooke. The Evil Queen was forcibly separated from Regina, but was able to stay around. Mr. Gold (aka the Dark One, aka Rumpelstiltskin) had relationship troubles with Belle. Together, they are trouble.
#9. The Butcher/Agnes (American Horror Story: Roanoke). Kathy Bates played two roles. She played the supernatural creature known as the Butcher on the “show within a show” My Roanoke Nightmare and she played the actress playing the Butcher on My Roanoke Nightmare. Agnes found herself sinking deeply into the role, taking the idea of method acting too far.
#8. Gordon Rimmer (Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency). Probably one of my favorite scenes on tv this year happened with Gordon. He had Dirk and Todd prisoner and they were sure that he would give them answers…only to find out that he didn’t know what was going on either. Classic!!!
#7. The Man in Black (Westworld). He turned out to be William, but the Man in Black was such a problem all year long. He was in search of the maze, but he was after more than that. He was after the challenge. He got it too. A great portrayal by Ed Harris.
#6. Cottonmouth (Luke Cage). Cornell Stokes, played brilliantly by Mahershala Ali, was the first antagonist in the Luke Cage Netflix series, and he was perhaps the best one. There were layers about this character and when he died at his cousin’s hand, the series went in an entirely surprising and different direction.
#5. Zemo (Captain America: Civil War). Some people complained that this was just another weak MCU villain, but I disagree. Zemo was great. He was a manipulator. He worked in the shadows. He could not fist fight with the Avengers, so he got them to do it for him. You understood why he did what he did and you could even relate to him. Daniel Bruel was great and, even better, this was like Zemo’s origin. More from him please.
#4. Harley Quinn (Suicide Squad). One of the best parts of Suicide Squad was the portrayal of Harley Quinn by Margot Robbie. While some people disliked Jared Leto’s Joker, everyone loved Harley. She brought a special charm to Suicide Squad and is in line for a movie of her own.
#3. Norman Bates (Bates Motel). This has been a slow burn. We knew that Norman would go psycho one day, but we hoped against it because Freddie Highmore was so damn charming and enjoyable. Well, he has succumbed to his insanity as he killed Norma in a failed murder-suicide attempt. His jealousy over Alex and Norma’s wonderful relationship finally pushed Norman to the side of evil. He had been moving that direction, but now there is no going back.
#2. Jervis Tetch (Gotham). The Mad Hatter has done the impossible. He made Gotham great again. Tetch and his craziness has been the driving force behind the new season of Gotham and he has brought that menace and that wickedness that they had been lacking among their other villains. The writing got better too, but Tetch stood out among them all.
#1. Negan (The Walking Dead). We waited all season 6 for him. We heard that Jeffrey Deam Morgan was cast as Negan and we all couldn’t wait. And then they dragged it out until the finale. AT the finale, we see him bludgeon someone to death. We had to wait for months before we found out it was Abraham. And then he killed Glenn too. And he broke Rick by almost having him cut off Carl’s hand. And he walked around with charisma to spare, being just downright evil. You hate the guy, but you love him as well. Negan is the villain of the year.
Worst Villains
#2. Lex Luthor (Batman vs. Superman). Jesse Eisenberg was the wrong choice… or perhaps the direction of Eisenberg was wrong…but this was not Lex Luthor. And that would have even been okay if they had just gone all in. As it was Eisenberg was playing a better Riddler or Toyman than Lex. Lex Luthor is too iconic of a villain to do that to.
#1. The Enchantress (Suicide Squad). She was just horrible. I did not hate the Suicide Squad, but this villain is just the worst of the year. Every one of the weak Marvel villains was much better than the Enchantress.

#8. Collider Movie Talk
#7. Movie Games with Jeremy Jahns
#6. Top Ten
#5. Collider TV Talk
#4. The Schmoes Knows Show
#3. Movie Trivia Schmoedown
#1. TV Fights

#4. Wes (How to Get Away With Murder). All season, we wondered who was beneath the blanket. The body that they hauled out of the fire at Annalise’s house was male, but that was about all we knew. Each week, we would discover another character who was “safe” but the producers of the show still had an ace up their sleeve. They were not playing with normal narrative story telling. When we thought Wes was safe, in reality, we were seeing a scene that happened before the discovery of the body. That fake out made it all the more shocking when the cover was pulled back and there was Wes’s burnt face.
#3. Poussey Washington (Orange is the New Black). Prison can be a dangerous place. Even the kind-hearted inmates could find themselves on the wrong end of fate. That is what happened to Poussey (Samira Wiley). She had spent most of the year in a happy prison relationship with Soso (Kimiko Glenn). Unfortunately, Poussey wound up at the wrong place at the wrong time and was accidentally suffocated by a CO during the break up of an originally peaceful protest. Poussey’s death has only started to affect the inmates on Orange is the New Black.
#2. Normal Bates (Bates Motel). I almost made this one number one, but I just could not get it over the top. We knew this was coming. We know how the story ends. Still, you couldn’t help bu hope that the canon of Psycho could be adjusted a bit. Norman (Freddie Highmore) planned on killing both himself and his mother, but only succeeded in one. What made this worse was that Norma had become happy with Alex Romero and this became the final point a jealous Norman needed. The “Mr. Sandman” scene was beautiful and the final breakdown of
#1. Glenn and Abraham (The Walking Dead). Who did Negan kill? The cliffhanger angered many, but it created a huge sensation for the Walking Dead premiere. And in the episode, the writers continued to taunt the audience before they finally revealed that Abraham was the survivor to taste the barbed wire from “Lucille.” That was not unexpected and if that was it, Abraham’s death would not have made this list. But Negan wasn’t done. Thanks to a mistake in judgement by Daryl (Norman Reedus), Glenn became the second victim of Negan, and everyone lost it. Very few if anyone expected Steven Yeun to die as well. After Abraham’s death, there was a release of tension. I know that I thought “Okay, Glenn’s safe.” The death of Glenn from the comics was at the hands of Negan and Lucille and this was going to be one of those examples of where the tv show and the comics took different paths. Except… then we saw the brutal murder. Glenn’s death left everyone devastated and looking for answers. These were answers that we have yet to get.
#1. Norma Bates and Alex Romero (Bates Motel). A complete surprise. Originally brought together for a way for Norma to get Norman into a quality mental institution, Norma and Alex blossomed together. Both people were damaged, but together they found comfort and love and understanding. The scene where Norma confessed her tragic backstory to Alex and he just accepts it makes you believe in love again. I was really surprised at how much I loved these characters together which made it all the worse when Norma was killed by her son because he was afraid of losing her to Alex. Alex’s grief over the loss of this woman was amazing and brought tears to my eyes. Alex is ready to come after Norman in season five so I worry about his own fate.

Pasty Walker aka Hellcat. I did not think I would like this, and the art is a little too cartoony for my taste, but the story has been very solid, and the characterization of Patsy Walker and her supporting cast is top notch. This is something original. That will be a theme on this list.
Nighthawk. One of the series that was cancelled too soon. It featured a new version of an old character dealing with very topical subjects. Yes, I prefer my heroes to be non-killers and Nighthawk is certainly that, but the stories are the most important aspect of a comic, and Nighthawk was excellent every issue.
Dr. Strange. The Dr. Strange Last Days of Magic story was very well done, but I will admit it felt like the Thor God Killer storyline. However, similar though it may have been, Dr. Strange was shown better in this series than he had ever been shown before. It was a book that you could not miss and when was the last time that the Sorcerer Supreme was in that boat?
Civil War 2. This event series has been epic. There have been a ton of shocking moments that make you think twice about the Marvel Universe. The conflict between Carol and Tony feels natural and both characters faced big problems from their involvement. I have not yet found out what is the resolution of the story, but it should be something that brings chaos to the Marvel Universe for years to come.
I enjoyed the last Moon Knight series, but the new series with Marc Specter in an asylum, not sure what is real and what is not, has been amazing. We still aren’t sure just what is going on and what is real. I love that sort of intrigue. We have known for years that Marc Specter was crazy. Taking that and playing with reality is a brilliant move and created one of the best comics of 2016. It would have been number one if it had not been for….

