Ebenezer

There have been a lot of versions of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol over the years including everyone from Bill Murray, Patrick Stewart, George C. Scott, Alastair Sim, Disney characters and the Muppets. You can add Johnny Depp’s name to that notable list after Ebenezer debuted this weekend.

You know the story. Ebenezer Scrooge is a lonely, cold-hearted, and greedy businessman in the Victorian-age London who hates Christmas. Three ghosts visit him to attempt to redeem him before he had to go through his afterlife carrying a dreadful chain, like his former partner Jacob Marley.

Jacob Marley is played in this version by Ian McKellen and we do not get enough of Magneto. Of course, Marley is used as he is in all versions of the story, as our introduction to the ghosts coming to haunt Scrooge.

Johnny Depp is excellent as Ebenezer Scrooge. He does an excellent job giving us the miser and portraying the rotten man. Johnny Depp has been missing from the big screen for awhile now, thanks to his own life drama, but it was great to see him back and embracing this iconic character so well.

The biggest criticism I have seen about this movie is the question of whether or not we needed another version of A Christmas Carol, and, if so, what exactly does this movie bring new to the story. I can say that there is not anything really new about the way the story is presented to the audience and could be considered unnecessary. However, even without anything new to say, Ebenezer was an enjoyable movie and I was connected to Scrooge and his tail.

In fact, the movie did make some changes to the characters of the charity collectors that we see in the beginning of the story, and these changes did not work for me. I am not sure that this little addition made the story any more interesting and, to be honest, I would have rather had it removed from the film. There were a few other adjustments the film made in the future section that I did not like as much, but it did not pull me out of the movie.

Ebenezer was extremely dark and had several horror elements to it, more than most versions of A Christmas Carol would have. The character designs were really good, especially the Ghost of Christmas Present (played by Tramell Tillman). The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come continues to be one of the scariest ghosts you will ever see.

I did not realize that Ron Weasley himself, Rupert Grint, was playing Bob Cratchit until the final scenes of the movie. I was very impressed with his take on Bob Cratchit.

If you are looking for something all new or different, this is not your film. If you are out to get Johnny Depp after his controversies, there is not much I can say about it. Haters will hate. I found this movie to be very entertaining and I enjoyed the more horror take on the Scrooge story. It may be somewhat too long, but I did not feel that. Overall, I think this is a worthy addition to the classic movies of A Christmas Carol.

3.5 stars

Merry X-Mas from EYG

Merry Christmas to all out there from EYG.

It’s not Christmas for me until I watch Muppet Christmas Carol. Of all the Christmas traditions, this is the one that I look forward to the most.

Among the dozens of adaptations, this is my ABSOLUTE favorite version of A Christmas Carol.

Michael Caine is the perfect Ebenezer Scrooge. He accomplished this feat by playing this completely straight. He played Scrooge, as he said, “like I’m working with the Royal Shakespeare Company” and not dancing, singing Muppets. Line delivery was spot on and the facial expressions brought Scrooge to life.

Another reason he is great in this film is that we see Scrooge’s humanity right off the bat. As soon as the Marley Brothers (preformed by Statler and Waldorf) showed up, you could see Scrooge begin to change. I have never liked the versions of Scrooge that feels as if he does not change until he sees his tombstone in the future. That feels insincere. Michael Caine’s work is just fantastic.

The movie is also a surprisingly accurate translation of Charles Dickins’ work. Many lines are exactly as they appear in the novel. I mean, of course, there are plenty of changes and adjustments to the film. It is narrated by a rat and a … whatever… in Gonzo the Great and Rizzo the Rat.

The design of the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Yet to Come are brilliant. The Ghost of Christmas Past is just a child Muppet, but it is, arguably, the creepiest of the three. This Muppet had the perfect touch of the uncanny valley to make her frightening. I love the Ghost of Christmas Present. He always reminded me of Santa Claus. Yet to Come is the classic Grim Reaper version and looked remarkable. The Jim Henson Company was at its best with this puppetry.

I am not ashamed to say that the scene where Kermit and Miss Piggy talk about the death of Tiny Tim breaks me every time I watch it. There is just something about Kermit and Miss Piggy grieving that is just unnatural.

There are some great songs in the film. The “Scrooge” anthem that started the film off is fabulous as is the “One Sleep ’til Christmas” sung by Kermit. Above all of them though, my favorite is the song sung by the Ghost of Christmas Present called “”It Feels Like Christmas.”

I am grateful that I can watch this at any time on Disney +.